Pizza restaurants

Main Street Pizza - OH 44830

4.6 118 reviews Closed 317 S Main St, Fostoria, OH 44830, United States

Discover this place

Main Street Pizza is a casual pizza restaurant located on South Main Street in Fostoria, Ohio. Specializing in a variety of unique and classic pizzas, the menu features standout options such as Buffalo Chicken, Pickle, and Pepperoni pizzas. The establishment occupies a modest, older building that operates primarily as a takeout spot rather than a traditional sit-down venue. Known for its flavorful, buttery thin crust and a distinctive sweet marinara sauce, the pizzas offer a balanced ratio of toppings to bread. Alongside pizzas, the menu includes hearty subs and creative specialty pies like the Big D and loaded baked potato varieties. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, reflecting a neighborhood feel driven by a hands-on owner and attentive service. While it does not offer beverage service on-site, Main Street Pizza remains a notable destination for residents seeking inventive, well-crafted pizza in a straightforward setting.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet
Trendy

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Main Street Pizza - OH 44830 before visiting.

Reviews for Main Street Pizza - OH 44830

4.6

118 reviews

100%

18%

Review highlights

Based on 118 reviews

Main Street Pizza in Fostoria, OH, is widely praised for its exceptional pizza quality, featuring a notably flavorful and buttery crust paired with a distinctive sweet marinara sauce. Customers frequently highlight the generous topping-to-crust ratio and the creative variety of pizzas, including unique specialty options. The restaurant maintains a casual, takeout-focused atmosphere, which some patrons describe as unpretentious and community-oriented rather than upscale. Service is often noted as friendly and accommodating, with staff willing to go the extra mile to ensure customer satisfaction. While the absence of beverage service has been mentioned as a minor drawback, the overall consensus underscores Main Street Pizza as a beloved local spot offering consistently delicious food and a welcoming environment, valued by both regulars and visitors willing to travel for its flavors.

Jordan Faeth

Oct 03, 2025

This is my favorite pizza place in town, by far. Try a thin crust, extra crispy. The crust is so buttery and flavorful. The sweet marinara is incredible too. The pizza is phenomenal and the subs are delicious too! Great ratio of topping to bread. I love this place

Hunter Ritter

Sep 22, 2025

The owner is the coolest guy I've ever met. Very nice and friendly atmosphere, with great service and great food. I almost always get the railroad ties. Well worth the 30 minute drive from where I live!

Vickie Hoff

Sep 05, 2025

Honestly hate the last rating on atmosphere so will explain...this is basically a take out restaurant in an old building...not a fancy sit down restaurant so trying to be honest. That stated it's a pizza joint with honestly the best pizza I've ever had with some amazing unusual pizzas as well! Trust me if you go won't be disappointed!

coleen meyers

Aug 28, 2025

We love the sweet sauce pizza and in error did not ask for it..I called them to reorder and they were so gracious to give us another pizza with the sweet sauce...we are and will continue to be a good weekly customer...the pizza is amazing!

Rochelle Dillow

Aug 05, 2025

We always love some Fostoria Main Street Pizza! This time we got the Big D pizza which is like a big mac pizza, the loaded baked potato pizza, and the cinnamon streusal pizza! The only downfall is they no longer serve drinks, but still worthy of 5 stars if you ask me! It's that good!

Nikki Kleba

Aug 04, 2025

Our favorite pizza place in town, and there are a lot to choose from! We LOVE the railroad ties. For the amount you get the price is a real bargain. The subs are enormous and so delicious. And of course the pizza is the star of the show with loads of toppings, great sauce. To top it all off they are FAST. When we call for pickup, we just put on our shoes and drive over and our food is always ready.

Jake Dieter

Jul 19, 2025

AMAZING..... all around great food, great service and very fast delivery.